The Official Feedback
I wasn't kidding when I said I would be back to post my eval of the MAC Oil Control Lotion and Prescriptives Virtually Fresh foundation. You doubters. The quick and dirty is as follows:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6042e/6042e7f716e4c955d2b4dc2ac8544a970eede96f" alt=""
MAC Oil Control Lotion
Love it. This stuff really does work. Delivers moisture to my skin still while really helping out with mid-morning/mid-day shine. Seriously reduces need to blot. Bravo, MAC.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/21293/21293f965425854f8f4c442c1cc172e70cd63973" alt=""
Prescriptives Virtually Fresh
Lukewarm. Like the even distribution of color. Like that it really does even out overall skin tone and create a consistent base for any coverup you need to add. Don't like that it dries just a tad on the powdery side, and is therefore a little more visible to the naked eye than one would probably prefer.
BONUS review:
L'Oreal Vive Pro
Not a huge fan. My hair doesn't really feel clean after using this stuff - rather, it feels a little weighted down and thick/uncooperative. Sorry, L'Oreal, I was really rooting for you on this one.